Management review is a crucial component of an ISMS that helps determine opportunities for continual improvement. Through management review, an organization assesses the performance and effectiveness of its ISMS, including reviewing opportunities for improvements and the need for changes to the ISMS, including the security policy and security objectives. References: ISO/IEC 27001:2013 Standard, Clause 9.3 (Management Review)
Comprehensive and Detailed In-Depth B . Correct Answer: The organization is focusing on direct costs associated with running specific processes. "Personnel, third-party services, and general fees" refer to operational costs of specific processes, not overall business operations. A . Incorrect: Cost of operations refers to the total business expenses, not individual processes. C . Incorrect: Potential cost of errors relates to risk assessment and impact analysis, not direct expenses. Relevant Standard Reference:
Question 48
在第三方認證審核中，保密性是審核計畫中的一個問題。選擇正確說明審計中保密功能的兩個選項
Correct Answer: C,D
Confidentiality is one of the principles of audit conduct that auditors should adhere to when performing audits. Confidentiality means that auditors should exercise discretion in the use and protection of information acquired in the course of their duties3. Auditors should respect the intellectual property rights of the auditee and other parties involved in the audit, and should not disclose any information that is sensitive, proprietary, or confidential without prior approval from the auditee or other authorized parties3. Auditors should also obtain the auditee's permission before using a camera or recording equipment during an audit, as these devices may capture confidential information or infringe on the privacy of individuals3. Therefore, these two options correctly state the function of confidentiality in an audit. The other options are either incorrect or irrelevant to confidentiality. For example, auditors are not forced by regulatory requirements to maintain confidentiality in an audit, but rather by ethical obligations and contractual agreements3. Observers in an audit team can access confidential information if they have signed a confidentiality agreement and have been authorized by the auditee3. Audit information can be used for improving personal competence by the auditor only if it does not compromise confidentiality or conflict with other interests3. As an auditor is always accompanied by a guide, there is still a risk to the auditee's sensitive information if the guide is not trustworthy or authorized to access such information3. References: ISO 19011:2018 - Guidelines for auditing management systems
Comprehensive and Detailed In-Depth Explanation: The Statement of Applicability (SoA) is a mandatory document in ISO/IEC 27001:2022 that lists all Annex A controls, their applicability, and justifications for inclusion or exclusion. * C. Correct Answer: The SoA must include justifications for excluding Annex A controls. The scenario states that the project team excluded certain controls but does not mention that justifications were documented. This violates ISO/IEC 27001 Clause 6.1.3 (Information Security Risk Treatment), which requires documenting exclusions with reasons. * A. Incorrect: While the SoA should include an exhaustive list of controls, simply listing applicable controls from Annex A and other sources does not meet the requirement if exclusions are not justified. * B. Incorrect: Including security controls from other sources is allowed and does not invalidate the SoA, as organizations can define additional controls beyond Annex A based on their risk assessment. Thus, Clinic's SoA is incomplete because it does not provide a justification for the exclusions of Annex A controls, making it non-compliant with ISO/IEC 27001 requirements.
According to ISO/IEC 27001:2022, which specifies the requirements for establishing, implementing, maintaining and continually improving an information security management system (ISMS), control A.5.29 requires an organization to establish and maintain a business continuity management process to ensure the continued availability of information and information systems at the required level following disruptive incidents1. The organization should identify and prioritize critical information assets and processes, assess the risks and impacts of disruptive incidents, develop and implement business continuity plans (BCPs), test and review the BCPs, and ensure that relevant parties are aware of their roles and responsibilities1. Therefore, when verifying the information security of the business continuity management process, an ISMS auditor should verify that these aspects are met in accordance with the audit criteria. Three options that will be in the audit trail for verifying control A.5.29 are: * Collect more evidence on how the organisation manages information security on mobile devices and during teleworking (Relevant to control A.6.7): This option is relevant because it can provide evidence of how the organization has implemented appropriate controls to protect the confidentiality, integrity and availability of information and information systems when staff work from home using mobile devices, such as laptops, tablets or smartphones. This is related to control A.6.7, which requires an organization to establish a policy and procedures for teleworking and use of mobile devices1. * Collect more evidence on how and when the Business Continuity Plan has been tested (Relevant to control A.5.29): This option is relevant because it can provide evidence of how the organization has tested and reviewed the BCPs to ensure their effectiveness and suitability for different scenarios, such as a pandemic. This is related to control A.5.29, which requires an organization to test and review the BCPs at planned intervals or when significant changes occur1. * Collect more evidence on how the organisation makes sure only staff with a negative test result can enter the organisation (Relevant to control A.7.2): This option is relevant because it can provide evidence of how the organization has implemented appropriate controls to prevent or reduce the risk of infection or transmission of diseases among staff or residents, such as requiring regular staff self-testing and using a health status app. This is related to control A.7.2, which requires an organization to ensure that all employees and contractors are aware of information security threats and concerns, their responsibilities and liabilities, and are equipped to support organizational policies and procedures in this respect1. The other options are not relevant to verifying control A.5.29, as they are not related to the control or its requirements. For example: * Collect more evidence by interviewing more staff about their feeling about working from home (Relevant to clause 4.2): This option is not relevant because it does not provide evidence of how the organization has established and maintained a business continuity management process or ensured the continued availability of information and information systems following disruptive incidents. It may be related to clause 4.2, which requires an organization to understand the needs and expectations of interested parties, but not specifically to control A.5.29. * Collect more evidence on what resources the organisation provides to support the staff working from home (Relevant to clause 7.1): This option is not relevant because it does not provide evidence of how the organization has established and maintained a business continuity management process or ensured the continued availability of information and information systems following disruptive incidents. It may be related to clause 7.1, which requires an organization to determine and provide the resources needed for its ISMS, but not specifically to control A.5.29. * Collect more evidence on how the organisation performs a business risk assessment to evaluate how fast the existing residents can be discharged from the nursing home (Relevant to clause 6): This option is not relevant because it does not provide evidence of how the organization has established and maintained a business continuity management process or ensured the continued availability of information and information systems following disruptive incidents. It may be related to clause 6, which requires an organization to plan actions to address risks and opportunities for its ISMS, but not specifically to control A.5.29. References: ISO/IEC 27001:2022 - Information technology - Security techniques - Information security management systems - Requirements
